TDNet Discover

The purpose of this mixed-methods phenomenological study was to investigate the decline in writing proficiency and the erosion of instructional time for composition for upper elementary and middle school students across the state of Oregon. For the utility of this capstone project, the decline in writing proficiency was generally defined as the diminishing ability of students to engage in deep, iterative drafting and the systematic marginalization of writing instruction due to high-stakes testing pressures and federal mandates. The theory guiding this capstone project was Vygotsky’s socio-cultural theory, as it emphasized the necessity of social interaction, peer review, and the zone of proximal development (ZPD) in the construction of literacy, which were the very elements sacrificed in a time-poverty environment. This study utilized a qualitative phenomenological design supported by quantitative data to address the primary research question regarding the perceived systemic and instructional causes contributing to the decline in writing skills among Oregon students. The setting included diverse educational environments throughout the state, featuring a sample of classroom teachers who provided anonymous perspectives through a structured survey on the challenges students faced within the literacy landscape. Data collection methods included an anonymous teacher survey and a comprehensive analysis of secondary state testing data. Thematic and trend analyses were used to demonstrate the systemic impact of high-stakes accountability on writing instruction, and results suggested that narrowed instruction reduced writing stamina, signaling a need for systemic shifts toward process-oriented composition.